S4 Ep 51: The History Of Watergate Cake With Guest Jen Ponton

In this episode of Sprung On Food, we get into the history of a dessert that’s as intriguing as its name, Watergate Cake. Joined by actor, Jen Ponton, who introduced me to this quirky confection.

Discovering Watergate Cake: A Personal Revelation

I’ll admit, when Jen first mentioned Watergate Cake, I was both intrigued and confused. As someone who loves all things cake and dessert, I wondered how such a richly storied cake had slipped past my radar. The thought of a pistachio-infused, green-tinted cake piqued my curiosity and lit a spark that I had to explore!

A Journey to the Past: The Seventies Scandal

As Jen and I chatted, we traveled back to the tumultuous 1970s, a time of cultural upheaval and uncertainty, but also of culinary innovation. Amidst the Watergate scandal, which gripped the nation, a whimsical bright green pistachio cake found its way into American homes. Big food companies like General Foods, with their newly introduced Jello pistachio pudding mix, gave rise to this trend. It was fascinating to dive into how this simple dessert, born out of a marketing campaign, became synonymous with American resilience and humor.

Baking Nostalgia: Jen's Family Connection

Jen shared her heartfelt connection with the cake, vividly recalling happy childhood memories tied to its baking. Her family’s version, loved for its simplicity and emotional significance, turned ordinary moments into celebrations. Inspired by these stories, I felt a deeper connection to this cake that transcended time and taste.

The Cake's Dual Identity: Sweet Surprise

But why call it Watergate Cake? As Jen and I explored the various theories, from jokes about its “nutty” nature to mysterious newspaper origins, the cake’s name seemed to capture both humor and historical reflection. Jen prefers the explanation that likens the cake to the scandal, a delightful mix of nuts and fluff, much like its namesake.

Reviving the Classic: A Modern Twist

Today, Watergate Cake is enjoying a resurgence. With Pinterest and TikTok bringing all things retro back into vogue, I find myself contemplating how this dessert combines the best of culinary satire with genuine deliciousness. Although our palates have evolved, the Watergate Cake’s charm and ability to tell a story through cake continue to hold a special place in our hearts.

A Cake Worth Celebrating

Embracing the spirit of experimentation, I now plan to bring Watergate Cake into my baking repertoire. I’m excited to share this newfound appreciation with friends and family, hoping to ignite the same joy it brought to Jen. After all, what better way to celebrate the resilient spirit of the past than with a slice of history?

You can watch each episode, in its video version, on YouTube here.
Follow on Instagram for some behind the scenes and short form content here.
Listen to each episode as a podcast on Amazon Music, Apple Podcast, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform.