S4 Ep 50: The History Of Goldfish With Guest Ryan Barton

Goldfish crackers are one of those foods that feel like they’ve always existed. They’re just there, in lunchboxes, on road trips, poured into bowls at parties, handed out without ceremony. On this episode of Sprung On Food, I sat down with comedy writer and performer, Ryan Barton, to really unpack how that happened, and why this tiny fish-shaped cracker became such a cultural constant.

Because when you actually slow down and look at Goldfish, they’re not just a snack. They’re a case study in how familiarity, design, and restraint can quietly build something lasting.

A Snack That Didn’t Start Loud

One of the things Ryan and I talked about early on is how Goldfish didn’t burst onto the scene as a novelty. They weren’t trying to shock or dazzle. They came from a place of simplicity, rooted in European cracker traditions, and eventually found their home within Pepperidge Farm’s growing portfolio.

What struck me is how intentional that evolution felt. Instead of leaning into gimmicks, Goldfish were allowed to become familiar first. The fish shape wasn’t a joke, it became an identifier. Something you could recognize instantly, even without a logo.

The Power of a Small Smile

We spent a surprising amount of time talking about the smiles, and for good reason. At some point, Goldfish crackers started smiling back, but not all of them. Only some. And that choice mattered.

Ryan pointed out how that decision transformed the experience of eating Goldfish. Suddenly, you weren’t just snacking. You were looking. Finding the smiling ones. Noticing the difference. It turned eating into something interactive without ever being loud about it.

It’s such a small detail, but it’s one of those moments where you realize how much thought goes into what feels effortless.

Flavor Without Losing the Plot

We also talked through how Goldfish expanded their flavors over time. New varieties came in, some stayed, some didn’t, but the core identity never shifted. No matter what the flavor was, it was still unmistakably Goldfish.

Ryan and I both kept coming back to this idea that the brand didn’t chase trends so much as it experimented within its own boundaries. There was room to play, but never at the cost of recognition.
That balance, between novelty and consistency, is harder to pull off than it looks.

Goldfish as Background Characters in Our Lives

One of my favorite parts of the conversation with Ryan was reflecting on how Goldfish exist almost in the background of our lives. They show up everywhere without demanding attention. They’re for kids, but also somehow for adults. They feel equally at home in a lunchroom or on a bar counter.

Ryan described them as invisible in the best way, and that stuck with me. Goldfish don’t need to announce themselves. They’re already welcome.

Why They Endure

By the end of our conversation, what became clear is that Goldfish didn’t become iconic by constantly reinventing themselves. They did it by trusting the original idea and letting it grow naturally.

Talking this through with Ryan reminded me that sometimes cultural staying power isn’t about being the loudest thing in the room. Sometimes it’s about being dependable, recognizable, and just a little bit playful, like a cracker that smiles back at you when you least expect it.

You can watch each episode, in its video version, on YouTube here.
Follow on Instagram for some behind the scenes and short form content here.
Listen to each episode as a podcast on Amazon Music, Apple Podcast, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform.