S4 Ep 11: The History Of Cookies And Cream Ice Cream With Guest Mitch Silpa
In this episode, we go into the history of cookies and cream ice cream. Known for its classic combination of rich vanilla ice cream and crunchy chocolate sandwich cookies, this flavor has captured the hearts and taste buds of many, becoming a staple in the realm of frozen desserts.
Meet Mitch Silpa
In this episode, we welcome actor and writer Mitch Silpa, who shares his love for cookies and cream ice cream. Growing up, Mitch didn't have a specific favorite food, but he fondly recalls the joy that ice cream brought him, even considering it as part of his last meal. Since its creation, cookies and cream has provided countless fond memories for those who indulge in its sweet, creamy pleasure.
Mitch's Relationship with Cookies and Cream
Though some may have once considered cookies and cream as “trash ice cream,” Mitch embraced this treat, undeterred by others' opinions. Sharing memories of enjoying caramel flavors and classic McDonald's sundaes, Mitch's love for ice cream is unabated by whimsical judgments of the past.
McDonald's Ice Cream Memories
Mitch's first job was at a McDonald's where he experienced firsthand the mystery of the infamous broken ice cream machines. While that detail remains an urban legend, Mitch fondly recounts his enjoyment of McDonald's shakes despite their tendency to be unavailable.
The Origin of Cookies and Cream Ice Cream
The journey of cookies and cream ice cream began in the late 1970s amid a wave of noteworthy innovations and cultural phenomena. While South Dakota State University claims its creation in 1979, many others, including Bluebell Creameries and Dreyer's Edy's, have laid claim to this illustrious invention. The truth may be buried within historical ambiguity, yet cookies and cream remains a beloved flavor—a testament to the simple genius of mixing creamy ice cream with crumbled cookies.
The Ice Cream Sleuth: Who Invented Cookies and Cream?
Pinning down the true inventor of cookies and cream would require a touch of detective work. Mitch humorously surmises that perhaps the development was a natural evolution, with many innovators arriving at the idea independently given its seemingly obvious appeal.
A Dive into Ice Cream's Rich History
While indulging in cookies and cream, one must appreciate ice cream's broader history. Originating in ancient China and spreading across Persia and Europe, frozen treats have delighted people for centuries. The Industrial Revolution made ice cream more accessible, giving rise to ice cream parlors and laying the groundwork for modern favorites like cookies and cream.
Cookies and Cream's Cultural Impact
Beyond ice cream, cookies and cream's influence extends into various culinary products and pop culture. The flavor inspired candy bars, video games, and even a movie, showcasing its widespread appeal. As cookies and cream continues to rise into the ranks of America's favorite flavors, it challenges even the classic vanilla for the spotlight.
Final Thoughts on Cookies and Cream
Mitch passionately expresses his adoration for ice cream sandwiches made with cookies—a fitting tribute to his favorite dessert. While nostalgia holds a place in his heart for favorites like Chipwiches, modern offerings inspire him to explore new variations and combinations with tried and true classics.
Cookies and cream holds a special place in the hearts of many, inspiring dreamy confections and delightful reflections. Whether through historical intrigue or pure enjoyment, it continues to be a cherished classic, welcoming everyone to indulge in its sweet embrace.
You can watch each episode, in its video version, on YouTube here.
Follow on Instagram for some behind the scenes and short form content here.
Listen to each episode as a podcast on Amazon Music, Apple Podcast, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform.