S4 Ep 9: The History Of Smoked Whitefish Salad With Guest Lynn Harris
In this episode, we’re joined by Lynn Harris, founder and CEO of Gold Comedy, who shares her unabated love for smoked whitefish salad on pumpernickel bagels. Her enthusiasm for smoked fish, with its mayonnaise-rich texture mixed with the distinctive flavor of pumpernickel, is infectious. Lynn adores the simplicity and richness of this combination, which she describes as her ultimate food bliss.
But why specifically pumpernickel? For Lynn, its unique flavor is an age-old favorite, adding depth and complementing the smoky whitefish in a way no other bread could.
A Brief History of Smoked Whitefish
Our journey takes us back to Eastern Europe, centuries ago, where communities turned to smoking as a method of preserving fish beyond their typical spoil date. Adapting to new lands, Jewish immigrants brought this fishy tradition to America, where the art of smoked fish met its ultimate accessory—a bagel.
The smoking process itself, described as therapeutic as the fish absorbs the brine before being enveloped in gentle, aromatic smoke, transforms whitefish into an enduring delicacy. With its nuanced, smoky aroma, it’s no wonder this practice has crossed oceans and transcended generations.
Kosher Delis: The Heartbeat of Community
As Jewish immigrants settled, they opened kosher delis, introducing America to smoked whitefish and more. These delis weren’t just eateries; they were community hubs where families gathered, shared stories, and indulged in lovingly prepared food. Being enveloped in the scent of smoked meats and fresh bagels while overhearing lively conversations in Yiddish was a sensory experience, and these delis remain cultural icons even today.
The Origins of Pumpernickel
Pumpernickel deserves its own spotlight for bringing its unique, earthy character to the table. Originating from Germany in the 15th century, this dense bread was humorously nicknamed “devil’s fart” due to the digestive effects attributed to its composition. Yet, its deep flavors have found a home in various cuisines, celebrated for its harmony with smoked fish.
Culture, Comedy, and Culinary Contributions
In popular culture, smoked whitefish salad and its deli companions have carved out notable spots. From Katz’s iconic scene in "When Harry Met Sally" to the vibrant Jewish food culture portrayed in "The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel," these foods are more than meals—they’re a testament to culinary heritage and community spirit.
Lynn Harris humorously notes, through family jokes and her life steeped in the comedy world, that essential Jewish gatherings wouldn’t feel right without the presence of fish. This sentiment resonates widely and highlights how food traditions like smoked whitefish are woven into the very fabric of these cultures.
Conclusion: Celebrate the Classics
In our modern world filled with culinary experimentation, Lynn warns against overcomplicating this simple pleasure. With a caution against adding blueberries or bee pollen to whitefish salad, she celebrates its timeless purity. As you savor your next meal, let smoked whitefish on pumpernickel serve as a reminder about valuing the simple, time-tested pairings.
We invite you to dig in, celebrate this storied tradition, and perhaps even experiment at home. Whether you're preserving history through your own homemade smoked fish or indulging at your local deli, remember the story of smoked whitefish salad and the humble, yet mighty, pumpernickel—it’s a classic that’s generations in the making.
You can watch each episode, in its video version, on YouTube here.
Follow on Instagram for some behind the scenes and short form content here.
Listen to each episode as a podcast on Amazon Music, Apple Podcast, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform.